Shane Reynolds and Scottywood defeats Mike Best (Shane gets the decision and title)
Gimmick: Handicap Steel Cage Match
Title Reign: 179 days
Show: Mayhem (10-17-11)
————————————————
Defenses
Shane Reynolds defeats Scottywood
Gimmick: Crucifixion Match
Show: RATR (11-3-11)
————————————————
Shane Reynolds defeats Scottywood
Gimmick: Hardcore Match
Show: Mayhem (11-18-11)
————————————————
Shane Reynolds defeats David Black
Gimmick: House of Mirrors Match
Show: ICONIC (12-23-11)
————————————————
Shane Reynolds defeats Darkwing
Gimmick: Singles Match
Show: Mayhem (2-20-12)
————————————————
Shane Reynolds defeats Silent Witness
Gimmick: Singles Match
Show: Mayhem (3-5-12)
————————————————
Shane Reynolds defeats Austin Reeves
Gimmick: Singles Match
Show: Mayhem (3-20-12)